TraditionKU wrote: ↑Sun Apr 12, 2020 10:26 am
TDub wrote: ↑Sun Apr 12, 2020 9:04 am
twocoach wrote: ↑Sun Apr 12, 2020 8:46 am
I agree with you that Seahawk's post was a gross generalization of what is happening in small town America. But I do believe that the majority of the brightest, most talented kids in these areas are leaving to pursue larger opportunities. Not all, obviously, but a majority percentage. It has been happening since the GI Bill started offering to send the spouses and children of dead WWII soldiers to college. Even before that, the Depression sent people fleeing for larger cities in anywhere in America where they felt they could find work. There were simply more opportunities.
The GI Bill sent my grandmother from a tiny town in Southern Illinois to college at Southern Illinois University after my Grandpa died serving our country as a fighter pilot trainer. That gave her the skills to leave her small town and move to Denver. Then it sent my Mom to college at CU and then Kansas.
My Dad's father did the opposite and chose to come back to his tiny town in Kansas despite his undergrad degree from Kansas and a Masters from Harvard. But of his three children, the only one who didnt move away to a larger city was his only kid that didn't go to college and even he moved to the rural outskirts of Kansas City. Of that kid's four kids, the only smart one moved away and became a pharmacist. The other three are all educated to at most a high school level and are a rural postal carrier with a string of bad marriages, a handy man/construction worker who has his work opportunities limited by a collection of DUI's and a moron who moved to Vegas to be a poker player.
So of those three generations of my family from two different small towns, there is a grand total of one person left in those two original small towns and that was my aunt, who after moving away to go to KU, took early retirement from her job as a teacher in KC to move back home to the family farm to care for my grandparents and who is still staying in the family home waiting to die from the end stages of 50 years of smoking.
It doesn't feel like this life story is out of the ordinary. It feels like most really small (less that 1k) towns are facing the same issue with the last three generations of families.
I dont disagree with the point of your post. My issue is with the perceived arrogance of those who think if you dont move to the city you cannot be a valuable, educated person. Your father is an example of that and my story is similar. I did not attend Harvard but I do have a masters. I chose to move out of the city and back to the rural areas because thats where I'm happy and it keeps me sane. I would argue that in this age it is technology, not prisons, that will allow people to live remote and function in some industries. Seahawks act of arrogance and superiority, the omnipotent one, is fucking tiresome.
i could be wrong, but i think you, my folks, and the like are in the minority of those that live rurally
in my experience, most are not as well-educated
I don't personally have any answers to dying small towns and have probably have come to think that maybe the best we can do is to give greater support to those towns that are of a larger size, but are not in the "City/Metroplex" designation. My background working on prison overcrowding led me to visit all the prisons in one state, write legislation to get people with non-violent records out, and I've worked with corrections folks and chaired the board of a small town juvenile facility, written grants for small communities to get funds to set up substance abuse programs and drug courts to keep people out of jail and prison.
You've mentioned private prisons and while they're still a small percentage, they have powerful lobbyists that try to extort funding for facilities, especially those in declining small towns. They're often badly run and try to keep up numbers of inmates to keep their contracts. The big change in privatization has largely been in local jails, where many people serve sentences that are under a year and that are misdemeanors. Private contractors also try to get food service contracts, health service contracts, and telephone contracts--and all need those numbers to stay high. Add the private prison lobbyists to the corrections workers union lobbyists and you have a pretty big lobby group that has a large vested interest in keeping people in prison even though crime rates have gone down.
I'd rather see money spent on scientific research, on lowering tuition at state colleges, on supporting college students, and on public schools than on creating a geriatric prison population because some people in the 1980s based their elections on changing to determinate sentencing.
And, as I said early on, I think that Coronavirus may cause a reversal of the trend to lengthy sentences even though Trump and his minions have said their intent is to keep ramping up those long sentences.
I supported Kamala Harris because I think that reducing prison populations and prison expenditures is such a high priority, but it's such a tricky area that it takes someone who's been on the prosecution side to be able to lobby for the changes required.
Don't inject Lysol.