Re: Where's the petri dish thread?
Posted: Thu Mar 12, 2020 10:57 pm
So would you like to hear something funny!!!1
All Things Kansas.
https://www.kansascrimson.com/boards/
I knew it.
Look, I'm as pissy as anyone about how we've fucked this up, but this is straight up bullshit. We can't do what China did because we're not China. There is nothing productive to learn from how totalitarian states deal with crises because, even if they deal with them better than we do, we CANNOT and WILL NOT do the same things. It's like trying to teach your dog to herd sheep by having him watch KU play defense. It's serves no purpose other than to point out the perceived inadequacies of our current regime.Feral wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 10:56 pm I'm thoroughly humiliated to be a physician and watch how incredibly inept our health care "system" is in its response to the pandemic. There will be consequences, not only in morbidity and mortality, but in the strains this puts on our society, especially on those with the least ability to handle it. It's bad enough how lame we look to the rest of the world, but the doctor/patient relationship is based on trust, and this is doing nothing but degrading that trust.
Please watch this video to see how another country is responding, and ask yourself how likely we are to see similarly effective measures, when/if the rate of infections continues to climb like it is. (Please spare me the cultural, political, differences, I get that, that's why I said "similarly effective".) And if you don't particularly care for Rachel Maddow, you'll like that she doesn't do much talking.
Funny you left Italy, where they're now selecting patients to treat using "catastrophe triage," off your list.zsn wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:02 pm Again, not to turn this into a politics thread.......but if I read the above posts (just on this page) I cannot help but realize the unanimous opinion that our current medical care is a complete failure and includes a call for a "Government run" testing/healthcare system (references to Germany and South Korea, not to mentions Singapore in a different thread).
Sappy, look at the bright side post: There were similar feelings about the government failing after 9/11 and the country came together.zsn wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:02 pm Again, not to turn this into a politics thread.......but if I read the above posts (just on this page) I cannot help but realize the unanimous opinion that our current medical care is a complete failure and includes a call for a "Government run" testing/healthcare system (references to Germany and South Korea, not to mentions Singapore in a different thread).
I agree. Last night's dramatic events were an inflection point.CrimsonNBlue wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:10 pmSappy, look at the bright side post: There were similar feelings about the government failing after 9/11 and the country came together.zsn wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:02 pm Again, not to turn this into a politics thread.......but if I read the above posts (just on this page) I cannot help but realize the unanimous opinion that our current medical care is a complete failure and includes a call for a "Government run" testing/healthcare system (references to Germany and South Korea, not to mentions Singapore in a different thread).
I went to the Costco zoo today and everyone was patient, kind and in surprisingly good spirits.
I think today is a turning point. The numbers are going to get worse before they get better, but we are finally starting to have the right sentiment.
CrimsonNBlue wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 10:43 pm I think the new tests are 8 hours and the tests in Korea are 5 hours.
Should have had those weeks ago.
Oh no, DC thinks it's "straight up bullshit"! If only I had included a disclaimer, I wouldn't be facing public ridicule by our resident public health expert. Woe is me. Woe is me!!!DCHawk1 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:05 pmLook, I'm as pissy as anyone about how we've fucked this up, but this is straight up bullshit. We can't do what China did because we're not China. There is nothing productive to learn from how totalitarian states deal with crises because, even if they deal with them better than we do, we CANNOT and WILL NOT do the same things. It's like trying to teach your dog to herd sheep by having him watch KU play defense. It's serves no purpose other than to point out the perceived inadequacies of our current regime.Feral wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 10:56 pm I'm thoroughly humiliated to be a physician and watch how incredibly inept our health care "system" is in its response to the pandemic. There will be consequences, not only in morbidity and mortality, but in the strains this puts on our society, especially on those with the least ability to handle it. It's bad enough how lame we look to the rest of the world, but the doctor/patient relationship is based on trust, and this is doing nothing but degrading that trust.
Please watch this video to see how another country is responding, and ask yourself how likely we are to see similarly effective measures, when/if the rate of infections continues to climb like it is. (Please spare me the cultural, political, differences, I get that, that's why I said "similarly effective".) And if you don't particularly care for Rachel Maddow, you'll like that she doesn't do much talking.
If LabCorp and Quest were involved there would be fifteen testing centers in every city but only fifteen people (if that) would get tested in each center. Since insurance companies could f#$# over anyone and everyone even that is likely an overestimation.DCHawk1 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:08 pmFunny you left Italy, where they're now selecting patients to treat using "catastrophe triage," off your list.zsn wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:02 pm Again, not to turn this into a politics thread.......but if I read the above posts (just on this page) I cannot help but realize the unanimous opinion that our current medical care is a complete failure and includes a call for a "Government run" testing/healthcare system (references to Germany and South Korea, not to mentions Singapore in a different thread).
Also, NO. If LabCorp and Quest Diagnostics were involved, that'd be fifteen testing centers in every city. The problem is bureaucratic sclerosis tied to demands for centralization, which is precisely the condition "Government run" anything exacerbates.
Sorry.Feral wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:38 pmOh no, DC thinks it's "straight up bullshit"! If only I had included a disclaimer, I wouldn't be facing public ridicule by our resident public health expert. Woe is me. Woe is me!!!DCHawk1 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:05 pmLook, I'm as pissy as anyone about how we've fucked this up, but this is straight up bullshit. We can't do what China did because we're not China. There is nothing productive to learn from how totalitarian states deal with crises because, even if they deal with them better than we do, we CANNOT and WILL NOT do the same things. It's like trying to teach your dog to herd sheep by having him watch KU play defense. It's serves no purpose other than to point out the perceived inadequacies of our current regime.Feral wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 10:56 pm I'm thoroughly humiliated to be a physician and watch how incredibly inept our health care "system" is in its response to the pandemic. There will be consequences, not only in morbidity and mortality, but in the strains this puts on our society, especially on those with the least ability to handle it. It's bad enough how lame we look to the rest of the world, but the doctor/patient relationship is based on trust, and this is doing nothing but degrading that trust.
Please watch this video to see how another country is responding, and ask yourself how likely we are to see similarly effective measures, when/if the rate of infections continues to climb like it is. (Please spare me the cultural, political, differences, I get that, that's why I said "similarly effective".) And if you don't particularly care for Rachel Maddow, you'll like that she doesn't do much talking.
If that's your response to seeing an example that we might learn something from for how to even begin attempting to flatten the curve on this pandemic in the US, I'm glad you aren't in a position to make public health decisions for Americans.
Before the COVID-19 outbreak ever appeared far away on the horizon, having participated in numerous types of disaster drills over the years, I would have assumed we had the infrastructure to at least begin to respond in an effective way, but by all appearances, we don't. Here, if a governor like Inslee of Washington or Cuomo of NY, or the CEOs of large corporations don't take steps to limit their employees exposure, where is that direction coming from? Certainly not the our government. Perhaps seeing examples of what's working is worth something. Prepping Americans for what's likely to come, even though we don't repeat the same protocols as the Chinese, can in no way hurt. Americans, as independent as we are, are still going to have to make changes in their lives, and getting used to the concept of being tested on an as needed basis, is only a first step in the process.
We need a denominator.
Oh.zsn wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:39 pmIf LabCorp and Quest were involved there would be fifteen testing centers in every city but only fifteen people (if that) would get tested in each center. Since insurance companies could f#$# over anyone and everyone even that is likely an overestimation.DCHawk1 wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:08 pmFunny you left Italy, where they're now selecting patients to treat using "catastrophe triage," off your list.zsn wrote: ↑Thu Mar 12, 2020 11:02 pm Again, not to turn this into a politics thread.......but if I read the above posts (just on this page) I cannot help but realize the unanimous opinion that our current medical care is a complete failure and includes a call for a "Government run" testing/healthcare system (references to Germany and South Korea, not to mentions Singapore in a different thread).
Also, NO. If LabCorp and Quest Diagnostics were involved, that'd be fifteen testing centers in every city. The problem is bureaucratic sclerosis tied to demands for centralization, which is precisely the condition "Government run" anything exacerbates.
Italy is an aberration because they got punched in the face before they knew what they were facing....now they're staggering to stand up.
All Hail Katie Porter!!