Kansas Crimson

but what if Qusdahl says "America bad" precisely because of the invasions?

Shoot, pretty sure PoliticoEurope got hacked by the Kremlin too

ousdahl wrote: ↑Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:52 pm but what if Qusdahl says "America bad" precisely because of the invasions?

Then that would mean Q missed the point

Ohhhh!

Qusdahl likes missing the point. That means the opportunity for new perspectives.

So what IS the point? Would you kindly identify, or does Qusdahl have to ask CoyDC again?

Mjl wrote: ↑Sat Nov 26, 2022 5:55 pm

ousdahl wrote: ↑Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:52 pm but what if Qusdahl says "America bad" precisely because of the invasions?

Then that would mean Q missed the point

Mjl wrote: ↑Sat Nov 26, 2022 5:55 pm

ousdahl wrote: ↑Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:52 pm but what if Qusdahl says "America bad" precisely because of the invasions?

Then that would mean Q missed the point

Are we so full of hubris that one of our administrators decided to look under a lamppost for keys we lost on a ski slope because that’s where the it was lit? Are we not able to criticize ourselves for invading the wrong country (Iraq instead of Saudi Arabia, who really had more culpability for 9/11)?

zsn wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 1:05 am

Mjl wrote: ↑Sat Nov 26, 2022 5:55 pm

ousdahl wrote: ↑Fri Nov 25, 2022 9:52 pm but what if Qusdahl says "America bad" precisely because of the invasions?

Then that would mean Q missed the point

Are we so full of hubris that one of our administrators decided to look under a lamppost for keys we lost on a ski slope because that’s where the it was lit? Are we not able to criticize ourselves for invading the wrong country (Iraq instead of Saudi Arabia, who really had more culpability for 9/11)?

What? No, you're missing the point too.

Yes, American invasions were bad. But far lefties, like Qus, instead of being for the defense of Ukraine, are instead, during this war, just blaming it on the US, because their takeaway was US bad, not invasions bad.

Yes, I did indeed miss some parts of the discussion and the context. I was just talking about the US invasion(s) in isolation.

Blaming US or Ukraine for the current situation that Ukraine is facing is basically surrendering to the Putin propaganda machine. I think splitting the West is really the motivation behind Ukraine invasion

zsn wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 9:08 am Blaming US or Ukraine for the current situation that Ukraine is facing is basically surrendering to the Putin propaganda machine.

Bingo.

soooo

Invasions = bad
American invasions = bad
America = not bad

that's quite the logic!

but please, keep doubling down about how it must be everyone else who is missing the point.

ousdahl wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 9:31 am but please, keep doubling down about how it must be everyone else who is missing the point.

Wow. The lack of self awareness is nearing an all time high.

everytime this thread is bumped I keep waiting for the big reveal that this has just been a ruse....a long play for Q to show his troll mastery.

zsn wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 9:08 am Yes, I did indeed miss some parts of the discussion and the context. I was just talking about the US invasion(s) in isolation.

Blaming US or Ukraine for the current situation that Ukraine is facing is basically surrendering to the Putin propaganda machine. I think splitting the West is really the motivation behind Ukraine invasion

is one even allowed to consider maybe there's blame to go around?

we've been up to some shady shit in Ukraine (among other places) for years. I just don't think that whatever we've been up to in Ukraine since at least 2014 can be so quickly dismissed. How do we so confidently shrug all that off as NOT contributing factors at all to the situation at hand today?

Cuuuuuz...here's the thing!

Like you asked rhetorically, we are like so totally NOT willing, nor able, to criticize ourselves when it comes to war and foreign policy and imperial meddling. Any attempt criticize America's actions is rabidly put down as bad guy propaganda. Honestly, I think Qusdahl's gotten as much heat as he/they has in this thread, for little more than attempting to criticize.

When Russia does it, we get so pissed off and clutch pearls and call on the entire world to retaliate; yet when we do it, the rest of the world is expected to just put up with it....let's just thank the fucking lord Russia hasn't been pumping arms and parading prominent Russian governmental figures around any of our own geographic neighbors, right? Particularly none of our own geographic neighbors who we've historically beefed with before anyway. Only Merica's allowed to do that!

Right?

And yes, I think a big motivating factor for Putin is splitting the West. But, if there is any divisiveness occurring in the West, I don't know if the blame for as much is solely and unilaterally Putin's. Again, it's a matter of whether we're willing or even able to criticize ourselves and our own gummint's actions.

Besides, I don't wanna give Putin that much credit! We've mentioned it before, but it's crazy how the rhetoric can simultaneously be "Putin's a deranged moron who doesn't know what he's doing and his entire effort is futile" and "Putin's a precisely calculated mastermind who is singlehandedly dividing the entire West"

TDub wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 10:02 am everytime this thread is bumped I keep waiting for the big reveal that this has just been a ruse....a long play for Q to show his troll mastery.

invasions bad
American invasions bad
America good
2+2=5

who's the trolls here, again?

I've tried to avoid bumping it lately cuz I've just accepted America at large, and posters on this bored in particular, just don't have much of a taste for actually paying attention to global politics, much less gaining anything more than some childishly oversimplified good guy bad guy narratives about it.

Mjl wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 8:33 am

zsn wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 1:05 am

Mjl wrote: ↑Sat Nov 26, 2022 5:55 pm

Then that would mean Q missed the point

Are we so full of hubris that one of our administrators decided to look under a lamppost for keys we lost on a ski slope because that’s where the it was lit? Are we not able to criticize ourselves for invading the wrong country (Iraq instead of Saudi Arabia, who really had more culpability for 9/11)?

What? No, you're missing the point too.

Yes, American invasions were bad. But far lefties, like Qus, instead of being for the defense of Ukraine, are instead, during this war, just blaming it on the US, because their takeaway was US bad, not invasions bad.

I think this post is telling - that you say "American invasions were bad," as if they're all just some thing of the past by now, some quaint chapter in the history books; and not still very much ongoing matters with contemporaneous consequences.

I guess that's how one is otherwise able to overcome the cognitive dissonance of "yea I know the US/NATO war machine totally derped us about Iraqistan, but no way those same powers would try to fool us again about Ukraine!"

3 posts in a row.

Ladies and gentlemen, please fasten your seatbelts.

ousdahl wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 9:31 am soooo

Invasions = bad
American invasions = bad
America = not bad

that's quite the logic!

but please, keep doubling down about how it must be everyone else who is missing the point.

Who said America = good? Yes, the fact that you injected that indicates you don't get the point. The point is that (US good or US bad), in the context of Russia invading Ukraine, isn't what matters. But you keep inserting it - which is exactly why I posted that. He's talking exactly about what you just did.

i say America=good.

MICHHAWK wrote: ↑Sun Nov 27, 2022 3:06 pm i say America=good.

America=Has its moments